Britney Spears’ memoir, The Girl In Me, particulars her relationship with Justin Timberlake and the press

If there’s a real, closing boss villain of Britney Spears’s long-awaited memoir, The Girl in Me, it isn’t her alcoholic and abusive father, who made thousands and thousands off her conservatorship and at one level claimed “I’m Britney Spears now.” Neither is it Lou Taylor, the architect of that conservatorship. It isn’t even Justin Timberlake, who broke Spears’s coronary heart by dishonest on her a number of occasions, convincing her to have an abortion when she was 19, then breaking apart along with her over textual content. The true villain? It’s the press.

The media, in spite of everything, heightened the dynamics of her relationship with Timberlake: Once they have been collectively, Spears remembers how the questions he’d get requested by discuss present hosts have been totally different from what they requested her. “Everybody stored making unusual feedback about my breasts, desirous to know whether or not or not I’d had cosmetic surgery,” she writes. (Like many celeb memoirists, Spears wrote the e-book with the assistance of a ghostwriter, on this case, the journalist and novelist Sam Lansky.) After they broke up, Timberlake went on Barbara Walters and performed an unreleased tune referred to as “Don’t Go (Horrible Girl)” that was clearly about her, and used the “Cry Me a River” video to win sympathy for himself and, in Spears’s phrases, paint her as a “harlot who’d damaged the center of America’s golden boy.” Whereas selling her 2003 album Within the Zone, nonetheless grieving the connection and feeling as if she was “not in a position to talk,” her father and a number of other handlers compelled her to sit down for an interview with Diane Sawyer during which the anchor demanded to know what Spears did to “trigger [Timberlake] a lot ache, a lot struggling.” “The interview was a breaking level for me internally,” she writes. “I felt one thing darkish come over my physique. I felt myself turning, nearly like a werewolf, right into a Dangerous Particular person.”

And it was the media who’d created the spectacle of Britney Spears through the fallout: Whereas she was pregnant along with her sons Sean Preston and Jayden James, the paparazzi tailed her whether or not she went out or stayed inside, utilizing decontextualized moments in time to painting her within the tabloids as unattractive or an unfit mom. “I bought cornered by the paparazzi with [Sean Preston] … they stored on taking my image as, trapped, I held him and cried,” she writes. “The magazines appeared to like nothing greater than a photograph they might run with the headline ‘Britney Spears bought HUGE!’ … At what level did I promise to remain seventeen for the remainder of my life?” She refers back to the paparazzi as “enemy combatants” who “appeared to multiply each time I checked.”

Dave Hogan/Getty Pictures

Britney Spears is way from the one well-known girl (or non-famous girl) to be vilified by the press, and positively not within the 2000s, a time when the tabloids have been much more vicious and sexist than they’re at this time, largely as a result of there was no real-time suggestions to stated sexism within the type of social media. However her story is maybe probably the most indicative of the media’s culpability within the struggling of all who discover themselves swept up in its power.

For those who’d solely examine her within the tabloids or watched daytime discuss exhibits, the story of Britney Spears is an easy one: A younger, stunning ingenue from the agricultural South comes from nowhere and takes over the music trade, instantly hailed as a bimbo intercourse object when she was simply an adolescent. Then, after a couple of years, Hollywood will get the higher of her and the celebrity begins to take its toll — immediately she’s partying too laborious, having children and failing to take correct care of them, and in the end having a number of public “breakdowns.” Lower to: the conservatorship, the Free Britney motion, and her eventual freedom. It’s the traditional rise, fall, then rise once more narrative that the press is raring to spew and the general public is able to eat.

The Girl in Me complicates that narrative, primarily by letting us be taught extra about Spears the individual. Spears, as she repeats a number of occasions over the course of her memoir, is “bizarre,” and the media has by no means recognized methods to deal with bizarre. Spears means it in a great way, the best way artists are sometimes bizarre: Throughout filming of the 2002 teen film Crossroads, she writes that she was unable to separate herself from her character even when the cameras stopped rolling, like unintentional Technique appearing. “I ended up strolling otherwise, carrying myself otherwise, speaking otherwise. I used to be another person for months whereas I filmed Crossroads. Nonetheless to today, I wager the folks I shot that film with assume, She’s slightly … quirky. In the event that they thought that, they have been proper.” She describes herself as “disturbingly empathetic” and that “what persons are feeling in Nebraska, I can subconsciously really feel regardless that I’m hundreds of miles away.” She remembers a time when, on a street journey, she and a good friend each felt the presence of God, or maybe aliens. “There have been so many occasions once I was scared to talk up as a result of I used to be afraid someone would assume I used to be loopy,” she says, and it’s a heartbreaking reminder of what folks did consider her.

Add that to the truth that Spears comes from a household with a lengthy historical past of violence, trauma, and abuse, the truth that she was all the time hounded by paparazzi, and the “bizarre” will get weirder. She describes her personal strangeness as being childlike — in the best way that she demanded white marble flooring in her Los Angeles residence even when the designers stated it could be harmful, in the best way she writes her emoji-laden and infrequently chaotic Instagram posts — largely stemming from childhood trauma. Beneath the conservatorship, she grew to become “a type of child-robot. I had been so infantilized that I used to be dropping items of what made me really feel like myself.” Venting on Instagram, she says, was her means of rebelling towards its strictures and beating again media narratives: “Possibly this has been a feminist awakening,” she says, “I suppose what I’m saying is that the thriller of who the actual me is, is to my benefit — as a result of no one is aware of!”

The media has educated the general public to view any aspect of weirdness as proof that one thing sinister is happening behind the scenes, nearly all the time implying both drug use or psychological well being struggles (and this was a time earlier than most magazines, newspapers, or discuss exhibits knew methods to speak about habit and psychological well being). The results haven’t worn off: Take, for example, the quantity of conspiracy theories that also abound over Britney’s “actual” whereabouts and well-being even after being free of her conservatorship, most of which come right down to skepticism of her Instagram posts and her self-presentation. Learn the e-book, nonetheless, and it’s clear that her Instagram isn’t a cry for assist — it’s Spears venting towards the system that used and exploited her. Of her private model, she says, “I by no means knew methods to play the sport. I didn’t know methods to current myself on any stage. I used to be a nasty dresser — hell, I’m nonetheless a nasty dresser.” She frames this as being dangerous on the sport of being well-known, and on some stage, she’s proper: Spears by no means knew when to talk and when to demur, methods to act, or what to put on. She’s anxious and distrustful. Nobody ready her for the media twister they’d despatched her into.

It wasn’t simply the photographers and the tabloids. In a single interview with Matt Lauer, he stored citing that “everybody” was asking, “Is Britney a nasty mother?” On the uncommon event she’d exit with Paris Hilton, the tabloids would name her a slut or an addict (Spears says she by no means took unlawful medication and by no means had an alcohol downside). When she was present process a devastating custody battle and separated from her youngsters for weeks, “out of my thoughts with grief,” the paparazzi captured her shaving her head in a hair salon; a couple of days later, they hammered her with questions till she snapped, hitting one among their vehicles with an umbrella. When she carried out “Gimme Extra” on the VMAs in 2007, simply after having a panic assault and operating into Timberlake backstage, Sarah Silverman referred to her youngsters as “probably the most lovable errors you’ll ever see,” and Dr. Phil referred to as the efficiency a “prepare wreck.” When she did an interview with Ryan Seacrest to advertise Blackout, the album she was most happy with in her total profession, all he requested have been questions like, “Do you are feeling such as you’re doing all the pieces you possibly can to your children?”

Then, when Spears’s father and Lou Taylor imposed the conservatorship, her mom used the press to realize sympathy for herself within the type of a extremely publicized, tell-all memoir. The media, in the meantime, by no means appeared to make a lot of the truth that Jamie Spears was an alcoholic who’d declared chapter, failed in enterprise, and was now in complete authorized management of his completed, millionaire daughter. It wasn’t till the Free Britney motion was years underway that the media started being attentive to the truth that probably the most well-known folks on the earth was underneath a guardianship normally reserved for aged individuals who can not care for themselves, and even then, the eye normally got here with an air of skepticism.

The journalists, producers, and publishers who formed the narrative round Britney weren’t the one folks profiting. Spears was always surrounded by a system of managers, handlers, and publicists who squeezed as a lot cash and a spotlight as they might out of her whether or not it benefited her or, extra typically, didn’t. Of the “virgin” persona that dominated her early profession, Spears writes, “My managers and press folks had lengthy tried to painting me as an everlasting virgin — by no means thoughts that Justin and I had been dwelling collectively, and I’d been having intercourse since I used to be fourteen.” When Justin accused Britney of dishonest in “Cry Me a River,” she was then slammed as a hypocrite, regardless that she’d by no means needed to be seen as a virginal function mannequin to start with.

It’s too dangerous that the general public didn’t get to see the “actual” Britney from the beginning. Younger feminine artists now are getting into a wildly totally different media panorama than she did; for one, they’ve extra energy to painting themselves in no matter means they need by way of social media, and plenty of of them, having constructed their careers on-line, don’t have an unlimited fame equipment round them instructing them on what to do and say (a part of that’s as a result of there may be considerably much less cash within the music trade than there was within the ’90s). The result’s that it’s uncommon for an artist to develop into as wealthy and well-known as Britney Spears, however they’ll probably have had extra autonomy alongside the best way.

The media, too, is totally different; it’s extra forgiving and fewer prescriptive (commenters on social media are, nonetheless, the other). However as a result of Britney Spears continues to be Britney Spears, she continues to be the topic of vicious rumor-mongering and irresponsible reporting from shops like TMZ and the Every day Mail, which because the finish of her conservatorship have tried to painting her as an unfit mom, an addict, and mentally unwell. After 20 years and limitless appeals to be left alone, Spears continues to be on the mercy of the tabloids, who together with a lot of the general public, anticipated that she’d “return to regular” as soon as the conservatorship ended.

With Britney, although, there isn’t a “regular.” Within the closing pages of the e-book, she tells us this herself. “I’m free now. I’m simply being myself and making an attempt to heal,” she says. “Freedom means being goofy, foolish, and having enjoyable on social media. Freedom means taking a break from Instagram with out folks calling 911. Freedom means having the ability to make errors, and studying from them. Freedom means I don’t need to carry out for anybody — onstage or offstage.” The media in 2023 nonetheless feels unprepared to deal with a Britney Spears — or any feminine celeb — who’s unconcerned with efficiency, who resides just for themselves, and who’s, by her personal description, bizarre. However hopefully she will be able to accomplish that anyway. She’s actually earned the proper.